Lifestyle

Defence of Christmas Consumerism

Each Christmas, every other article and blog post complain about how commercialized Christmas has become, how it’s lost it’s true meaning beneath a mountain of gift wrap. Last year, my family of three celebrated our first Christmas together sleeping beneath the tree with lots and lots of presents. I celebrate Christmas for many reasons, one of which are the gifts. I mean really, who doesn’t love presents? I love presents!!

What’s wrong with buying gifts during the holiday season? Some Scrooges extol the virtues of holiday abstinence and have given up gift giving all together. To them, I say bahumbug! Gift giving is one aspect of consumerism that I can get onboard with.

Gift Giving: What is it good for?

The minimalists and the anti-materialism-ists will have you believe that “the reason for the season” is long forgotten and that Christmas nowadays is all about senseless consumption of things that don’t matter. They paint a picture of obligatory gift exchanges, wishlists created with the expectation of receiving, and masses fighting their way to sales, consuming for the sake of consumption. However, without some degree of consumerism, there would be little in the way of showing gratitude and experiencing generosity; Christmas consumerism is good for something.

Four things, in fact.

Express Love

My brother is not big on words or for showing affection (what is it with boys?); he expresses his love and appreciation towards his family by showering them with gifts. His gifts are always thoughtful and generous and make the receiver feel special. Gift giving is an expression of love as much so as a hug and a kiss or saying the words “I love you”.

Show Gratitude

Daniel was laid off shortly after we were married. It was a difficult time; we were a young couple with school debt on a single income. My parents really helped us out by buying us groceries every so often and slipping cash into our pockets for us to furnish our empty home. Once Daniel started working again, we decided to save extra hard to get my mum a Louis Vuitton bag for Christmas. It was something she’s always liked but would never buy herself. It was our way of saying thank you.

Keep Traditions

One of my favourite things about Christmas is our traditional family gift exchange. Some years we do Secret Santa, some years we buy presents for everyone, but every year there are riddles and decoys. One Christmas my dad presented a big box to my then twelve year old sister. She unwrapped with bright eyes to find a box with a picture of a modem. “I got you unlimited internet! Now you can use the internet without my permission,” said my dad. My sister’s eyes clouded over with disappointed. She continued to open the box to find a lovely sweater she wanted.

Another year, my dad bought my mum a magnify glass to help with her farsightedness; she was not pleased and berated my father while we, kids, rolled on the floor dying with laughter. She, in return, got him five Tim Horton’s gift cards that had been gifted to her over the year; she didn’t know the balance on any of the cards and admitted to having perhaps used one or two. We bought my dad a flask that year and then raided his stash to supplement his gift with a bottle of his finest liquor (I didn’t have the time to go the LCBO before the gift exchange). My dad, pleased with the choice of liqour said, “oh! I have a bottle of this”, later to yell “Hey! this is MINE!”

Whether it’s a gag gift (my dad’s specialty), a regift (my mum’s speciality), or gifts that don’t appear as they seem, the point isn’t the presents itself, but the act of gift giving together as a family.

Experience Generosity

What would be of generosity if it wasn’t for the act of giving gifts? Last Christmas, my mum’s sisters lavished our baby son with big expensive plastic toys. To be completely honest, I can do without the toys (not big on plastic, not big on big things in a small space), but their generosity touched me. They had gone out and picked out toys they thought Lucas would love and they were willing to spend the money on him, knowing that it would bring him brief moments of amusement. Receiving undeserved gifts are a privilege and they should be accepted with gratitude.

The Gift of the Magi

A short story titled “The Gift of the Magi” was published in 1905; the story was about a young couple who show the depth of their love to one another by the gifts they give. In short, they both sell the one possession which they take pride to buy the other the perfect present.

Gifts are a way to outwardly communicate an inward expression of gratitude and love. Holiday shopping doesn’t come without it’s challenges – crowded parking lots and overflowing malls characterize the insanity – but the true act of giving requires sacrifice of time and money. Generosity brings families and friends closer together and instills a sense of joy that is in line with the true meaning of the Christmas season: a gift of the baby born in a manger on a silent night.

You Might Also Like

  • Kelly December 12, 2013 at 9:57 PM

    I agree completely. Assuming people are remembering the true meaning of Christmas, I think it’s okay to go nuts and buy gifts for people you love. I do feel like sometimes the politics of gift giving will land you in not the most honest place, but that is another story. There really is so much in the act of gift giving that can be truly wonderful.

    I say remember to say Happy Birthday to Jesus, and then go give His peeps some gifts!

    • Emily December 14, 2013 at 10:30 AM

      I think gift giving is important for people who don’t celebrate the birthday of Jesus; if there reason for the season isn’t the gift of Christ, then shouldn’t it be at least about generosity and love? As you said, I think it’s okay for people to go nuts; but by “going nuts”, I most certainly don’t condone crazy consumerism, such as going into debt, making gift giving (and subsequently spending) the first focus, or how Jingle All the Way (the movie) represents Christmas.

  • dojo December 13, 2013 at 9:51 AM

    We don’t give gifts anymore, it’s useless most of the time. I’m 35 now, earn a very good income and, if I need something, be certain I buy it for myself. I don’t need ‘santa’ to bring me anything, not to mention that, as I get older, I start disliking the idea of receiving gifts since they’re rarely something I really like. We’re all grown up, so we don’t need this, not to mention that, if my family needs something (or I just find in the store something they would clearly love), I purchase it any time of the year. I don’t need a holiday to remember I have them.

    Things will change once our daughter is born,we’ll try to keep traditions for her and make sure she has nice holidays. It doesn’t mean we’ll gonna break the bank with the gifts, but we’ll clearly make sure she is not deprived in this area.

    • Kelly December 13, 2013 at 2:43 PM

      You’re one of the people I hate buying gifts for!!! 😉

      I see your point. which is unfortunate for people like me who love to buy gifts for people. I love it. It makes me happy. but I also like to make other people happy, so when I’m stuck not being able to buy anything for I get a little sad.

      but to each her own.

      I also earn a good living. But I struggle to treat myself to things because I don’t *need* it. That’s where gift giving is nice. Like Emily, I have brothers who aren’t great are showing generosity. Christmas helps them with that.

      • Emily December 14, 2013 at 10:59 AM

        I love buying gifts for people as well because it makes them happy which then brings me joy.

    • Emily December 14, 2013 at 10:42 AM

      I understand the feeling of receiving something I don’t like. In those cases, it’s usually because the giver put little thought into the present and only give because they think is expected from them; that’s something I don’t think captures the heart of Christmas and want to avoid.

      My family and friends have everything they need and I like to use Christmas as an opportunity to purchase things they want but won’t get for themselves.

      Last year was my son was only six months at Christmas. We wanted to start our holiday family tradition of gift giving then. He like the wrapping paper more than his presents we had a lot of fun! You will be filled with the same wonder and joy when you celebrate your daughter’s first Christmas and keep your family traditions, and of course, you won’t break the bank or go overboard or stress.

  • Erin @ My Alternate Life December 13, 2013 at 2:54 PM

    I’m not doing gifts this year, instead I am taking my family out to dinner. It is a lot easier to do it this way because I live across the country and flying with a bunch of gifts is not my idea of a good time 🙂

    I don’t think there is anything wrong with gift giving, it’s when gifts are the sole focus of the holidays that I cringe a bit. Balance is great — family, friends, food, gifts, decor, and music all have their place in the holidays. But hopefully family and friends are #1 🙂

    • Emily December 14, 2013 at 11:02 AM

      Hi Erin, I think taking your family out for dinner is a lovely and practical idea, especially since you’re travelling for the holidays.

      Yes, gifts should be the focus of the holidays. It should a platform to show love and gratitude to the number ones (family and friends).